Close button
Join BirdBot Newsletter
Computer Vision Assisting in Wildlife Initiatives
Contact us: admin@bird.bot

Best Bird Seed Mix for Wild Birds: What to Buy & Avoid

May 23, 2022

Black oil sunflower seeds are widely considered the most versatile and attractive option for backyard feeders, appealing to a broad range of species including cardinals, jays, and woodpeckers. For targeted feeding, safflower is effective for cardinals, while niger (nyjer) attracts finches. High-quality mixes should prioritize whole seeds and nuts over fillers like wheat or milo, which many backyard birds ignore. Always provide clean water and clean feeders regularly to maintain bird health.

Understanding Seed Types and Nutritional Value

Not all seeds are created equal. The nutritional density and shell thickness of a seed determine how much energy a bird gains from it and how much waste is left on the ground. Understanding these differences helps you choose the right feed for the birds you want to attract.

Black Oil Sunflower Seeds

Black oil sunflower seeds are often called the "perfect birdseed" because they offer a complete nutritional profile with thin shells that are easy for birds to crack. They are high in oil and protein, making them an excellent energy source for flying birds. These seeds attract a wide variety of species, from large-billed cardinals and woodpeckers to smaller finches and sparrows. Because the shells are thin, there is less waste compared to striped sunflower seeds, which have thicker, harder shells that many small birds cannot open.

Safflower Seeds

Safflower is a popular choice for attracting cardinals while discouraging squirrels and some other non-target species. It provides a nutritious alternative to sunflower for seed-cracking birds and is generally well-tolerated by a variety of backyard species.

Niger (Nyjer) and Millet

For smaller birds like goldfinches, juncos, and pine siskins, niger (often spelled nyjer) is a top choice. It is a small, black seed that is high in oil. Red millet is another good option for ground-feeding birds and smaller songbirds. While millet is nutritious, it is often used as a filler in lower-quality mixes because it is less attractive to many common backyard birds than sunflower or safflower.

Nuts and Fruit

Nuts provide high energy and are favored by woodpeckers, nuthatches, and jays. When selecting mixes with nuts, look for whole or large pieces rather than small crumbs, which can be wasted. Fruit pieces, such as raisins or papaya, can add variety and appeal to finicky birds, though they should be a supplement rather than the primary component of the diet.

Ingredients to Avoid

While most commercial bird seeds are safe, some ingredients should be strictly avoided. Avocado is the most critical item to exclude; it contains persin, a toxin that is harmful to birds and can cause serious health issues or death. Never offer avocado, whether fresh or dried. Additionally, always avoid mixes that contain fillers like wheat, oats, or milo if your goal is to attract specific songbirds, as these are often ignored by the birds you are trying to feed, leading to waste and potential mold growth. Moldy or spoiled seed should be removed immediately, as it can carry harmful fungi.

Comparing Popular Bird Seed Mixes

Commercial mixes vary in quality, price, and target species. Below is an overview of several popular options, highlighting their general composition and intended audiences. Always check the specific product label for the most current ingredient lists and nutritional information.

Lyric Wild Bird Mix

Illustration for Choosing the Right Bird Seed: A Practical Guide for Backyard Feeders
Lyric Wild Bird Mix - 40 lb.

This 40-pound mix is designed for beginners, offering a cost-effective blend with a significant portion of sunflower seeds and multiple nutritional ingredients. It aims to attract a wide variety of birds, including cardinals, doves, finches, and sparrows.

Kaytee Wild Bird Food Nut & Fruit Seed Blend

Kaytee Wild Bird Food Nut & Fruit Seed Blend For Cardinals
Kaytee Wild Bird Food Nut & Fruit Seed Blend For Cardinals

This premium blend combines sunflower and safflower seeds with added nuts and fruit pieces. It is formulated to meet the high-energy demands of flying birds and is suitable for year-round feeding. The mix is designed to attract cardinals, chickadees, nuthatches, and woodpeckers.

Pennington Songbird Nut & Fruit Blend

Pennington Songbird Nut & Fruit Blend Wild Bird Seed
Pennington Songbird Nut & Fruit Blend Wild Bird Seed

Enriched with vitamins and minerals, this blend targets colorful songbirds such as indigo buntings, chickadees, pine siskins, finches, and cardinals. It is suitable for hopper, gazebo, and tube-style feeders. The mix is designed to provide a balanced diet for backyard birds.

Audubon Park Songbird Blend

Illustration for Choosing the Right Bird Seed: A Practical Guide for Backyard Feeders
Audubon Park Songbird Blend Wild Bird Food

This 14-pound blend focuses on safe, natural, and nutritious ingredients. It is marketed as a high-quality option for attracting and feeding backyard birds.

Lyric Supreme Wild Bird Mix

Lyric Supreme Wild Bird Mix
Lyric Supreme Wild Bird Mix

This mix contains a variety of premium ingredients, including large black oil sunflower seeds for big-billed birds, nuts for woodpeckers and nuthatches, and small seeds like white millet and niger for finches and juncos. It is positioned as a high-value option for feeding a wide range of backyard birds.

Valley Farms Black Oil Sunflower Seed

Illustration for Choosing the Right Bird Seed: A Practical Guide for Backyard Feeders
Valley Farms Black Oil Sunflower Seed

This is a straight seed product, meaning it contains only black oil sunflower seeds. It is sold in a 25-pound bulk bag and is noted for its cleanliness and plumpness. This seed is a favorite among evening grosbeaks, cardinals, tufted titmice, pine siskins, sparrows, nuthatches, jays, and woodpeckers.

Lyric Cardinal Premium Sunflower and Safflower Mix

Lyric Cardinal Premium Sunflower and Safflower Wild Bird Mix
Lyric Cardinal Premium Sunflower and Safflower Wild Bird Mix

Specifically designed to attract cardinals, this mix features a high proportion of sunflower seeds and golden safflower. The thin hull of the safflower makes it easy for birds to eat and digest. This blend is ideal for attracting large-beaked species like cardinals, jays, and grosbeaks.

Wagner's Songbird Banquet

Wagner's Songbird Banquet Wild Bird Food
Wagner's Songbird Banquet Wild Bird Food

This mix includes black oil and striped sunflower, peanuts, safflower, and tree nuts. It is formulated to attract a wide variety of songbirds. The blend is designed to provide all-natural nutrition and keep birds coming back to the feeder.

Audubon Park Songbird Selections Multi Wild Bird Food

Audubon Park Songbird Selections Songbird Selections - Multi Wild Bird Food with Fruits and Nuts
Audubon Park Songbird Selections Songbird Selections - Multi Wild Bird Food with Fruits and Nuts

This 5-pound blend includes a variety of nuts, fruits, and seeds, including sunflower, peanuts, millet, and raisins. It is enriched with vitamins and minerals to support immunity, energy, and reproductive health. The mix is designed to attract chickadees, cardinals, nuthatches, titmice, jays, and woodpeckers. It comes in an easy-to-reseal bag for storage.

Lyric Fine Tunes No Waste Bird Seed Mix

Lyric Fine Tunes No Waste Bird Seed Mix
Lyric Fine Tunes No Waste Bird Seed Mix

This mix is made with edible ingredients, including peanut pieces, sunflower kernels, and various nut pieces. It is designed to attract goldfinches, chickadees, finches, jays, nuthatches, and bluebirds. The "no waste" label indicates that every ingredient is intended to be consumed by birds.

Wild Delight Songbird Food

Wild Delight Songbird Food
Wild Delight Songbird Food

This advanced formula is designed to help birds maintain high levels of health, growth, and reproduction. The mix is suitable for a variety of songbirds and is marketed as a health-focused option.

Best Practices for Feeding Birds

When setting up feeders, consider the following tips to maximize bird visits and ensure their health:

  • Placement: Place feeders at different heights to reduce conflict between different species. For example, larger birds may prefer lower feeders, while smaller birds may feel safer in higher, tube-style feeders.
  • Water: Always provide clean, fresh water near the feeders. Birds need water for drinking and bathing.
  • Cleaning: Clean feeders regularly to prevent the spread of disease. Remove any moldy or spoiled seed immediately.
  • Consistency: Feed birds consistently, especially during winter and migration, when natural food sources may be scarce.
  • Observation: Keep a log of which birds visit your feeders and which seeds they prefer. This can help you adjust your mix over time to better suit the local bird population.

Reading the Feeder: Species-Specific Cues

Understanding how different species interact with food can help you identify visitors and optimize your setup. Cardinals are often seen perched on the edge of feeders, using their strong, conical beaks to crack open large sunflower or safflower seeds. They tend to be bold and may dominate larger feeders. In contrast, finches like goldfinches and pine siskins are more agile and often cling to the sides of tube feeders or niger thistle feeders, using their small, precise beaks to extract tiny seeds. Woodpeckers and nuthatches are frequently found on suet feeders or platforms, where they can cling to vertical surfaces and access nuts and high-energy fats. By observing these behaviors, you can better understand which species are utilizing your feeders and adjust your offerings accordingly.

By choosing high-quality seeds and maintaining clean feeders, you can create a welcoming environment for a diverse range of backyard birds. Whether you are a beginner or an experienced birder, the right seed mix can make a significant difference in the number and variety of birds you attract.

Further Reading